My two cents in the discussion about virtual education (an excerpt from The Confession Of The Creative Brain).
I wrote a lot about education, including the distant education.
More on this page.
Here I want to point out at the useless but very active discussion how to effectively use Zoom for teaching.
The answer is - you CANNOT effectively use Zoom for teaching.
Zoom, Skype, WebEx, Google Meet, Microsoft Teams, or any other meeting software will never be good for teaching.
Of course, to understand and accept that, one needs to know what teaching is and is about.
In
American culture, including the top educators, researchers and
administrators teaching is not different from animal training, from
training circus animals doing tricks.
If
teaching would have been pouring knowledge from a "knowledge storage"
(a.k.a. a teacher) into an empty vessel (a.k.a a student) then Zoom
would be sufficient. But teaching is not that.
E.g.:
Teaching
is the process of helping learners to learn. And learning is based on
communication. If one-on-one communication would have been possible,
then, again, Zoom would be fine. But that is not a case. Teaching
requires an effective group communication. That requires a an ability to
organize, manage and monitor communication between students. That
requires s completely different technological instrument.
A
teacher needs to be able to see and not just all students, but the work
of every (any!) student (and of course communicate with any student).
And a teacher needs to be able to create and re-create collaborative
groups and observe the group work and participate in that work. And this
is just the bare minimum any teaching collaborative technology must do.
Ideally, students should feel immersed in the same learning
environment, and that means - use virtual reality. The need to do
laboratory experiments brings even more demands to an effective distant teaching-and-leaning technology.
To my best knowledge, there is no company or a startup trying to develop that technology.
Hence, distant teaching sucks, and will continue to suck for years ahead.
Dr. Valentin Voroshilov

For curious people - a reward!
No teaching technology can do any good if a teacher who uses it sucks.
Unfortunately, the vast majority of teachers in America sucks at teaching. It is not their fault, though. America dose not have a system of teacher professional development (well, America does not believe in systems in general, and look what she got herself into).
E.g. this post, or this one (from many!).
The roots of American decline - in all spheres, including education, starting from education! - is the extreme primitivism practiced by the managers of all levels.
America! The victim of the Primitivism.
No comments:
Post a Comment